Greens Slam Plan To keep Historic Town Hall Open

Written by Harry Turnbull

A row has erupted in Wirral over plans to use a costly town hall while a new £75m council office development is half-empty.

Green party councillors have slammed the ‘extravagant’ decision to use Wallasey Town Hall by Labour and Tory members which could cost council taxpayers £1.6m a year.

Instead they want to see council meetings and services like the registry office switched to one of the new blocks, named Mallory and Irvine, where council staff already occupy four of the five floors.

Cllr Jo Bird said “The work needed on the town hall building is £12m which would amount to £1.2m a year borrowing costs plus the £400,000 a year to run various services. It is an extravagant waste of council money adding more pressure to council budgets which could then in turn lead to cuts to frontline services.

“There is an obvious common-sense solution and that is to move into the Mallory building which can accommodate council meetings and civic services like the registry office.

“The Council could save a lot of money by temporarily standing down Wallasey, as well as Birkenhead Town Hall, while seeking other organisations to bring these historic and listed buildings back into use for the long term.”

The council has already spent £9.2m fitting out Mallory and says furnishing the remainder of the building would be another £3m.

Councillors in the opposing parties claim the waterfront town hall is an important part of the area’s heritage. A report is also being compiled on what to do with Birkenhead Town Hall, another costly Grade ll listed building.

Wirral Council borrowed £75m from Canada Life Asset Management on a 35 year repayment deal for the construction of two office blocks, nicknamed Mallory and Irvine after two mountaineeers with local links. George Mallory and Sandy Irvine disappeared in 1924 just a few hundred yards from the summit of Everest.

Three-quarters of the Mallory is occupied by council staff but attempts to fill the remaining space and find occupants for Irvine have so far been unsuccessful. This could cost the council £3.9m next year in rent and lost rental fees.

Council finance officer Matthew Bennett said mothballing the two town halls which are listed buildings would also be very costly and taking more space in Mallory would also mean less space to let out to commercial tenants.

However councillors on the policy and resources committee rejected a suggestion further cost analyses were necessary and opted to keep Wallasey Town Hall for day to day functions and to pursue options for Birkenhead.

Meanwhile councillors are also awaiting a report on cost-cutting for services with the budgetary deficit forecast to be £21m this year.