Stanlow Oil Refinery

Written by Harry Turnbull

Billions of pounds earmarked for a massive eco scheme in the North-West has been blasted by environmentalists.

The government’s flagship carbon capture plan is not planet friendly and will end up costing astronomical amounts of cash that could be used more effectively, some claim.

Hynet will involve constructing a 62 mile long underground pipe running through the region to service EET Fuels’ Stanlow plant near Ellesmere Port which captures low carbon hydrogen.

Cadent Gas, the project leader, and other stakeholders are now putting the proposals out for public consultation, claiming it is a massive win for the green agenda.

It’s a view not shared by some campaigners.

Responding to reports that the government will announce plans to invest £22bn over twenty five years in carbon capture and storage projects, Friends of the Earth’s head of policy, Mike Childs, said:

“Whilst millions of people are facing a winter of freezing in their heat-leaking homes, oil and gas executives will be celebrating. Rather than properly fund a home insulation scheme for those unable to afford it, this announcement essentially uses taxpayer money to subsidise the continued lifespan of the fossil fuel industry.

“Blue hydrogen, championed by the fossil fuel industry and produced from gas with carbon capture and storage, is not clean; there are fugitive emissions from extracting the gas and not all of the carbon emissions from manufacturing it can be captured.

“The government needs a coherent industrial strategy to secure genuine green jobs and switch to clean energy. It must reject the false solutions peddled by the fossil fuel industry and use the forthcoming budget and spending review to spell out how it will address the UK’s under-investment in making homes affordably warm and energy efficient.”

Oil company EET Fuels which operates the refinery at Stanlow says 600,000 tonnes of Co2 will be captured annually but critics say it will actually create new emissions. The counter argument will not be presented to the public.

Rob Donovan, project director for the scheme, said: “This latest design includes changes made thanks to previous community feedback.

“We encourage local communities and authorities, as well as industry partners to share their views on these more detailed plans, to help us further develop our designs ahead of submitting our application for consent. The feedback we receive is crucial to ensuring the success of our proposals.”

HyNet North West is intended to produce, store and distribute hydrogen as well as capture and store carbon from industrial sites.

Project chiefs said it will be the UK’s first 100 per cent hydrogen network. Once the final design has been developed.They claim the £22bn investment will enable the faster, greener, collective re-industrialisation of the region, allowing UK companies to successfully compete in international low carbon markets and win new business.

But environmental campaigner George Monbiot says there’s a reason why oil and gas companies have lobbied so forcefully for this policy: it licenses continued fossil fuel production. He said the government’s decision has been sold as a way to deliver blue hydrogen. This means hydrogen made from fossil gas, as opposed to green hydrogen, which is made by electrolysis with renewable electricity. He says it will also cost vastly in excess of the mooted £22bn initial bill.

For information about the consultations visit https://hynet.co.uk/have-your-say/